Your external hard drive stopped working, so you did what plenty of people do: opened the plastic case, took out the drive and connected it to a PC with a SATA cable or a desktop dock. Instead of your folders, Windows shows the disk as unallocated, RAW, the wrong size, or pops up a message asking you to format or initialise it. It looks as if everything has gone. In many cases it has not. The data is usually still sitting on the platters, and the way the drive is now connected is the reason it cannot be read. This guide explains why that happens and what to do before you make it worse.
Why a drive can look empty once it is out of its case
An external hard drive is normally an ordinary SATA hard drive plus a small circuit board, called the USB bridge, that sits between the drive and your computer. On many models that bridge does more than pass data through. Two things in particular change how the drive looks to a computer.
- Sector size translation. Some external drives, including various Western Digital My Book and Elements desktop models and some Seagate desktop drives, have a USB bridge that presents the disk to the computer as if it used 4096-byte sectors. The bare drive inside reports 512-byte sectors when connected directly. The partition table written through the USB bridge records positions in 4096-byte units, so when the same disk is read in 512-byte units the partition appears in the wrong place or not at all. Windows then shows it as unallocated or RAW, and the reported size may look odd.
- Hardware encryption. Some WD My Passport and My Book models, and some other brands, encrypt everything on the bridge board automatically, even if you never set a password. Out of the case, the drive holds only scrambled data that no ordinary computer can read. We cover this in more detail in our guide to diagnosing WD hard drive problems.
In both situations the drive is not necessarily faulty at all. It is simply being read in a way that does not match how the data was written.
Symptoms that point to this problem
- Disk Management shows the drive with the correct manufacturer and roughly the right capacity, but the space is unallocated or the partition is RAW.
- Windows asks “You need to format the disk before you can use it” or prompts you to initialise the disk as MBR or GPT.
- A Mac says the disk is not readable and offers Initialise, Ignore or Eject.
- Recovery software finds a jumble of files with wrong names, or nothing useful at all.
- The drive was working, or at least spinning normally, before you removed it from the case.
If the drive is clicking, beeping, grinding or not spinning, you are dealing with a physical fault instead, and the advice is different: switch it off and do not keep trying it in different docks.
What not to do
- Do not initialise the disk. Initialising writes a new partition table over the old one. It is one of the most common ways a recoverable drive becomes much harder to recover.
- Do not format it, even with a “quick” format, to see if that helps.
- Do not run CHKDSK or partition repair tools. They will try to “fix” a file system that is not actually broken, just being read with the wrong sector size, and their changes can damage it.
- Do not write anything to the disk, including recovered files. If you try recovery software, any output must go to a different drive.
- Do not throw away the original case and bridge board. For hardware-encrypted models the bridge board can be essential for getting the data back.
Safe steps you can take
- Stop and note what you did. Write down which messages appeared and whether anything was clicked, such as Initialise or Format. This information helps whoever works on the drive next.
- Put the drive back in its original case, if the case and its board are undamaged, and connect it with the original cable and power adapter. If the original problem was a broken USB socket, a failed power adapter or a faulty cable, the drive may now read normally once that part is replaced with a matching one.
- Copy the data off immediately if it reads, to a separate drive, starting with the most important folders.
- If the bridge board itself has failed, a replacement board from the same model is not always enough, particularly where encryption is involved. This is the point to get professional help rather than buying spare parts online.
- If the drive makes unusual noises or the data appears corrupt even in its original case, switch it off. A drive with weak heads or bad sectors can deteriorate each time it is powered on.
How a data recovery lab deals with it
A lab handles these drives by first making a sector-by-sector image of the disk, so all further work happens on a copy rather than the original. Where the problem is sector size translation, the partition layout can be read correctly from the image without changing anything on the drive. Where the bridge board encrypted the data, the work depends on the specific board and model, which is why keeping the original electronics matters. If the drive also has a physical fault, that is dealt with in our clean room before imaging. You can read more about our hard drive data recovery service in London.
Need help with a drive that looks empty?
If your external drive shows as unallocated, RAW or asks to be formatted after being removed from its case, stop before initialising or repairing anything. Call Data Doctor on 020 7394 2529 for a free initial consultation, or bring the drive, its case and its power adapter to us at Unit 1, The Willows, 80 Willow Walk, London SE1 5SY. You can also see our data recovery services across the UK.